Introduction
Five Songs Barry Gibb Never Expected to Become Massive Hits
Barry Gibb is one of the most successful songwriters in music history, yet he readily admits he could not always predict which tracks would conquer the charts. Several of his biggest classics were written casually, nearly shelved, or doubted by the very people involved in making them. Here are five iconic hits that grew far beyond Barry Gibb’s expectations.
“Stayin’ Alive” (Bee Gees)
Written for the Saturday Night Fever soundtrack without the brothers ever reading the script, “Stayin’ Alive” was never intended to be a dance track. To Barry, it was an R&B song about surviving the gritty streets of late-1970s New York, and he even resisted producer Robert Stigwood’s push to rename it “Saturday Night.” Despite Barry’s belief that people could not dance to it, the song topped the Billboard Hot 100 for four weeks in 1978, defined the disco era, and later found an unexpected purpose: medical organizations worldwide now recommend its 103-beats-per-minute tempo to guide chest compressions during CPR.
“Heartbreaker” (Dionne Warwick)
In 1982, the Bee Gees wrote “Heartbreaker” for Dionne Warwick, who initially disliked the song and felt it did not suit her style. Rather than abandoning it, Barry persuaded her to record it anyway and discard it afterward if she still felt the same. Warwick trusted him, and the patience paid off. Released in 1983, the track became Warwick’s biggest solo hit of the decade, selling roughly four million copies and reaching the top 10 in over a dozen countries.
“Chain Reaction” (Diana Ross)
While producing Diana Ross’s 1985 album Eaten Alive, the Gibb brothers held back “Chain Reaction” because they feared its deliberate 1960s Motown sound would offend Ross by making her feel pushed back into her Supremes era. Only when Ross needed one final track did Robin Gibb convince her to try it. She loved the tribute, and the single went on to spend three weeks at number one in the UK.
“Grease” (Frankie Valli)
Asked in 1978 to write a title song for the movie Grease, Barry had no idea how to approach the word. Sitting in his lounge watching television, he casually sketched the entire song in about an hour and did not think much of it. Given to Frankie Valli, the track surged to number one on the Billboard Hot 100 and became inseparable from the blockbuster film.
“How Deep Is Your Love” (Bee Gees)
Ironically, Barry Gibb’s favorite Bee Gees song is the one he doubted most. Originally intended for singer Yvonne Elliman, the soft ballad felt completely out of place amid the 1977 boom of punk rock and loud disco. Yet manager Robert Stigwood insisted the Bee Gees record it themselves. It spent three weeks at number one, won a Grammy, and became an enduring standard—proving that even a master hitmaker can occasionally underestimate his own magic.