Introduction
In 2005, a young Oklahoma singer named Carrie Underwood captivated the nation and won the hearts of millions on her way to becoming the fourth American Idol winner. Two decades later, in 2025, she made her grand return to the very stage that launched her career—this time, as a judge. Taking over for the popular Katy Perry during the show’s 23rd season, her appointment was initially met with overwhelming excitement. Fans saw it as a full-circle moment, a powerful testament to her incredible journey from hopeful contestant to global superstar. However, as the season has progressed, a more mixed reception has emerged, with some viewers questioning her performance and commitment to the role.
From Fan Favorite to Controversial Judge
On paper, Underwood’s transition to the judging panel seemed like a perfect fit. As one of the most successful alumni in the show’s history, with a staggering eight Grammy Awards and countless number-one hits, she brought instant credibility and star power. Her insider perspective as a former competitor was expected to offer a unique blend of empathy and experience. Alongside returning judges Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie, her presence was meant to breathe new life into the long-running series and potentially boost its recent decline in ratings.
In a press release, Underwood herself expressed her excitement, stating, “This show gave me my start, and I’m honored to give back by helping new artists chase their dreams.”
However, the initial excitement has been tempered by a growing chorus of criticism on social media. Many fans have described her judging style as stiff, reserved, or overly cautious compared to her predecessors. “Carrie is not bringing the same energy Katy Perry did,” one user commented, with another adding, “She’s too polite and doesn’t give enough constructive criticism. It’s like she’s afraid to say anything real.”
The general consensus is that Underwood’s quiet demeanor and ambiguous feedback have not translated well to the judging table, creating a stark contrast with her dynamic stage presence. This has led many to feel that her approach lacks the personality and flair needed to keep viewers engaged.
Filling Katy Perry’s Shoes
A key factor in this backlash is the legacy of her predecessor, Katy Perry. Over her seven seasons, Perry became a defining force on the show, known for her larger-than-life personality, emotional investment in contestants, and unapologetic spontaneity. While Perry’s style was sometimes divisive, it was undeniably a major source of drama and entertainment.
Underwood, by comparison, seems to represent a safer choice by producers—a move to avoid controversy and capitalize on a beloved figure from the show’s past. Yet, for some fans, this shift has left a void. “Carrie is great, but Katy added the drama and the heart,” a fan wrote. “The panel just feels flat now.”
The Question of Commitment and the Future of Idol
As the season winds down, a new question looms large: will Underwood return for a second season? Her jam-packed schedule, which includes a thriving music career, a fitness company, and a family life with her husband and two sons, raises doubts about her long-term dedication to the show.
While the feedback hasn’t been entirely negative—some fans admire her sincerity and believe she has room to grow—the overall sentiment suggests a difficult road ahead. The move to bring her back was a nostalgic attempt to recapture the show’s golden era, but the underwhelming response indicates that the formula may need a fresh approach.
Will Carrie Underwood find her voice as a judge and return for another season, or will she choose to step away, leaving fans to wonder what could have been? Only time will tell if this highly anticipated homecoming will be the triumphant return everyone hoped for or a one-season experiment that ultimately fell short.