Introduction:
AMERICAN IDOL CONTROVERSY: Why Some Fans Want Thunderstorm Kicked Off the Show
After advancing to the Top 12 on American Idol, contestant Thunderstorm is facing heat from some viewers who believe his previous reality TV experience gives him an unfair advantage over the competition.
The latest elimination round saw Thunderstorm secure his spot in the Top 12 of American Idol. While the talented singer has a strong fan base, his advancement has sparked a debate on social media about whether he should even be on the show.
The controversy stems from Thunderstorm’s history on another major singing competition: he previously competed on The Voice in 2020, where he made it to third place. Since then, he has built a substantial online following, boasting over 85,000 followers on Instagram and more than 40,000 on other platforms.
Is His Experience Unfair?
Many fans argue that Thunderstorm’s previous exposure gives him an unfair advantage over newcomers. One critic on social media argued that he “already knows what to expect” compared to contestants who have never faced the demands of a national televised competition.
However, other viewers strongly disagree, defending the singer’s right to compete.
“Hard disagree. He is allowed to be on the show, same as others who also have been on other shows,” one fan wrote. “It’s like saying medalists on sports shouldn’t be allowed to compete again. They came here to get more boosts, more fans, and more experiences. This show isn’t just about finding new talents.”
Another supporter noted that in the “real world,” people compete with varying levels of experience, and American Idol is no different.
Despite the controversy, Thunderstorm is now focused on the next challenge. The live competition is set to continue, with two more singers eliminated on Monday night to determine the Top 10.